3 July 2023 in The Bookish Gossips, Book Reviews and Recommendations

Unveiling the Twilight Saga (2005): A Victim of Cancel Culture and Misunderstanding

Twilight Book Review

In recent years, the phenomenon of cancel culture has swept through society, often resulting in the hasty condemnation and dismissal of individuals, works of art, or cultural phenomena. One such victim of this trend is the beloved Twilight series, written by Stephenie Meyer. Despite its immense popularity and widespread acclaim, Twilight has faced relentless criticism and backlash, branded as unworthy and problematic. In this blog, we will explore why Twilight became an unfortunate target of cancel culture while other similar series, such as “Vampire Diaries” and “After,” have thrived.

The Rise of Twilight

Twilight burst onto the literary scene in 2005, introducing us to the world of Bella Swan and her love interest, the enigmatic vampire Edward Cullen. The series quickly gained popularity, captivating readers with its immersive love story and the eternal struggle between vampires and werewolves. In the ethereal town of Forks, WASHNGTON, Twilight unfolds as a captivating tale of forbidden love and supernatural intrigue. Bella Swan, a young and introspective teenager, moves from the sun-soaked plains of Phoenix to the rain-drenched landscapes of the Pacific Northwest. Little does she know that her life is about to take an extraordinary turn.

Also Read: My Fault 2023 film (Culpa Mia)

In this shadowed town, Bella becomes enchanted by the enigmatic Edward Cullen, a handsome and mysterious young man with a dark secret. Unbeknownst to her, Edward is a vampire, immortal and haunted by a hunger he resists with unparalleled discipline. Despite the danger that lurks within their connection, an undeniable and intoxicating bond forms between them, defying all rationality and societal expectations.

As Bella unravels the truth about Edward’s supernatural nature, she must grapple with her own desires and the knowledge that their love could come at a grave cost. Encountering a world of immortal beings, Bella’s existence becomes intertwined with a coven of vampires, each with their own unique powers and backgrounds. She faces perilous challenges and life-threatening situations, testing her own strength and resilience.

However, their love story is further complicated by the presence of Jacob Black, a loyal and warm-hearted member of the Quileute tribe. Jacob’s friendship with Bella grows into something deeper, revealing a love triangle fraught with tension and heartache. Bella finds herself torn between her profound connection with Edward and the genuine affection she feels for Jacob, leaving her to navigate the treacherous waters of her own heart. As the narrative unfolds, a menacing force emerges, posing a grave threat to Bella and those she holds dear. In a thrilling climax, the supernatural forces converge in a battle for survival, testing the boundaries of love, loyalty, and sacrifice.

Enduring Cultural Impact

Despite the criticism it has faced, Twilight undeniably left an indelible mark on popular culture. The series inspired a generation of readers, fostering a renewed interest in vampire mythology and fantasy romance. It sparked conversations, fan art, and even spin-off works that continue to engage fans worldwide. The enduring cultural impact of Twilight demonstrates its significance and the undeniable connection it forged with its audience.

Misunderstandings and Stereotypes

One of the primary reasons behind the backlash against Twilight was the misunderstanding and misrepresentation of its themes and characters. Critics accused the series of promoting unhealthy relationships, depicting Bella as a passive and dependent protagonist. However, this overlooks the complexities of Bella’s character and her agency in the narrative. The intense love between Bella and Edward, while unconventional, is rooted in their supernatural circumstances and is not meant to be a blueprint for real-life relationships.

The Role of Femininity

Another aspect that drew criticism was the portrayal of femininity in the series. Bella embodies the complexities of teenage emotions and the struggles of finding one’s identity amidst love and supernatural circumstances. Bella’s character serves as a relatable figure for many readers who have navigated the challenging terrain of adolescence.

Credit: Amazon

Though initially portrayed as a seemingly ordinary teenager, Bella’s character gradually evolves into a resilient and determined individual, making her own choices and facing adversity with courage. However, this empowering aspect of her character was overshadowed by unfair claims that she was portrayed as weak or reliant on Edward. Such interpretations failed to acknowledge Bella’s personal growth and her unwavering dedication to protect her loved ones.

Targeting a Female-Dominated Fanbase

Twilight gained a fervent and dedicated fan base, which, unfortunately, also contributed to the backlash. The passionate enthusiasm of Twilight fans was often met with ridicule and mockery, creating a vicious cycle of negativity. The widespread dismissal of the series and its fans further fueled the cancel culture surrounding it.A critical factor in the backlash against Twilight is its primary audience: young women.

Unfortunately, this led to the series being unfairly dismissed as mere “teenage girl fiction.” The derision aimed at Twilight was often rooted in sexism and a lack of respect for genres predominantly enjoyed by women. The disparagement of Twilight’s fanbase and their genuine love for the series reflects a broader issue of undervaluing female perspectives and interests in the literary and entertainment world.

The Power of Social Media

Twilight faced numerous misinterpretations that perpetuated negative stereotypes. Critics often overlooked the series’ deeper themes of self-discovery, choice, and the exploration of moral complexities. Instead, they focused on simplified and misleading portrayals, disregarding the nuanced discussions that the series prompted. By reducing the series to its surface-level tropes, detractors failed to recognize its true depth and potential for meaningful reflection.

The rise of social media platforms provided a platform for amplifying criticisms and promoting cancel culture. The ease of sharing opinions and joining virtual communities created an environment where hate and negativity could thrive. This resulted in a relentless wave of online attacks against the series, its author, and its fans. It became prominent to hate Twilight was seen as “cool” and so, the individuals who didn’t know the plot or characters of the series took part in its scrutiny and excoriation.

Impact on the Author and Fans

The hate and cancel culture surrounding Twilight had far-reaching effects. Stephenie Meyer, the author, faced immense criticism and public scrutiny, which impacted her personal and professional life. Additionally, Twilight fans found themselves marginalized and silenced, unable to express their love for the series without fear of judgment or ridicule.

It is important to acknowledge that artistic preferences vary from person to person. Just as different individuals enjoy different genres of music or literature, it is only natural that some may resonate more with the Twilight saga compared to other vampire-themed series. Rather than hastily dismissing Twilight based on personal biases or popular trends, it is essential to respect and embrace the diverse range of literary tastes that exist.

Moving Forward: Learning from Imperfect Portrayals

When it comes to teenage romance books and series, it is rare to find portrayals of completely healthy relationships. Many popular titles, including “The Vampire Academy,” “After,” “Sex Education,” and “Never Have I Ever,” often showcase relationships that are marred by complexities and flaws. While these stories explore themes of love, desire, and coming-of-age, they often delve into the darker aspects of relationships, highlighting the complexities and challenges faced by young individuals navigating their emotions.

By presenting imperfect relationships, these narratives aim to reflect the real-life complexities of teenage romance and spark discussions around topics such as consent, communication, and personal growth. It is crucial for readers and viewers to approach these portrayals with a critical eye, fostering open conversations about healthy relationship dynamics and promoting positive role models within the genre.

Twilight’s journey from a beloved literary phenomenon to a victim of cancel and hate culture is a testament to the power of public opinion and the influence of social media. While the series is not exempt from criticism, it is essential to approach it with nuance and an understanding of its context. Twilight sparked a cultural phenomenon, inspiring countless readers and leaving an indelible mark on popular culture. It serves as a reminder that even in the face of intense scrutiny, art can still find a place in the hearts of those who resonate with its themes and storytelling.




Leave a Reply

By browsing this website, you agree to our privacy policy.
I Agree